Precision1 for Astigmatism vs. MyDay Toric
If you have astigmatism, you’ve likely seen the contact lenses Precision1 for Astigmatism and MyDay Toric. They’re two commonly prescribed daily contact lenses designed specifically to keep vision stable throughout the day.
That said, they aren’t interchangeable. While both are daily disposable toric lenses, they use different materials and technologies, which can affect how they feel, how stable they are on your eye, and how they perform over long wear.
Your eye doctor will ultimately determine which lens is right for you based on your prescription, corneal shape, and tear film.
This guide walks through how Precision1 for Astigmatism and MyDay Toric compare, including comfort, stability, and cost.
Before comparing them directly, let’s take a look at each lens individually.
Precision1 for Astigmatism
Precision1 for Astigmatism is a daily disposable toric lens, meaning you wear a fresh pair each day and discard it at night. There’s no cleaning routine, no solution, and no buildup from previous wear.
It’s made from Verofilcon A, a silicone hydrogel material that allows oxygen to pass through to your eye, which is important for both comfort and long-term eye health.
What makes Precision1 unique is its SmartSurface technology. Instead of being fully water-based at the surface, it has a thin, highly hydrated outer layer designed to help the lens feel smooth and comfortable.
It also uses a stabilization design to help the lens stay in place, which is especially important for astigmatism, where even slight rotation can affect your vision.
Key Features of Precision1 for Astigmatism
- Replacement schedule: Daily (single use)
- Material: Verofilcon A silicone hydrogel
- Water content: ~51% overall, >80% at the surface
- UV protection: Yes, built-in UV blocking
- Technology: SmartSurface moisture layer + toric stabilization design
MyDay Toric
MyDay Toric is also a daily disposable lens designed for astigmatism.
It’s made from Stenfilcon A, another silicone hydrogel material that’s known for being lightweight and breathable. It allows a high level of oxygen to reach the eye while maintaining a soft, flexible feel.
MyDay Toric uses CooperVision’s Optimized Toric Lens Geometry, which helps keep the lens stable throughout the day and corrects astigmatic vision effectively.
Stenfilcon A material is designed to feel soft on the eye while still holding its shape well.
Key Features of MyDay Toric
- Replacement schedule: Daily (single use)
- Material: Stenfilcon A silicone hydrogel
- Water content: ~54%
- UV protection: Yes, built-in UV blocking
- Technology: Optimized Toric Lens Geometry for stability
Replacement Schedule
Precision1 for Astigmatism and MyDay Toric are both daily lenses.
You open a new pair each morning and throw them away at night. There’s no need for contact lens solution, no cleaning routine, and no buildup from previous days.
For many people, daily lenses are the easiest and most comfortable option to maintain.
Comfort
Precision1 for Astigmatism
Precision1 for Astigmatism is designed to feel smooth and lightweight, especially when you first put it in.
The SmartSurface layer helps keep the outer surface hydrated, which can make the lens feel comfortable throughout a typical day of wear.
MyDay Toric
MyDay Toric tends to feel slightly softer overall.
Both lenses are comfortable, and the biggest difference often comes down to preference; some people prefer a slightly more structured feel, while others like a softer lens.
Stability and Vision
For astigmatism, stability is one of the most important factors.
Precision1 for Astigmatism
Precision1 for Astigmatism generally provides consistently clear vision, though, like most toric lenses, slight movement can happen, especially if your eyes are dry or irritated.
MyDay Toric
MyDay Toric’s Optimized Toric Lens Geometry is designed to keep the lens in position throughout the day, which can help reduce fluctuations in vision.
For some people, this results in slightly more consistent clarity, especially during longer wear.
UV Protection
Both lenses include built-in UV protection.
This helps reduce the amount of ultraviolet light reaching your eye, but it doesn’t replace sunglasses. Contacts don’t cover your entire eye, so wearing UV-blocking sunglasses is still important when you’re outside.
Cost
Cost is often one of the biggest deciding factors.
Precision1 for Astigmatism is typically more affordable than MyDayToric.
MyDay Toric is usually priced slightly higher, but its extra softness is often totally worth the price difference for many people.
At Blue Planet Optics, both lenses ship free with no hidden fees. When you buy 3 boxes, you get the 4th 40% off, which can make a noticeable difference over time.
Which Lens Should You Choose?
Both Precision1 for Astigmatism and MyDay Toric are strong options.
Precision1 for Astigmatism may be a better fit if you want a more affordable daily toric lens or prefer a slightly more structured feel.
MyDay Toric may be a better choice if you prefer a softer lens or wear your lenses for longer hours.
Ultimately, your eye doctor will determine which lens is best for you.
FAQ
Can I switch between Precision1 for Astigmatism and MyDay Toric?
You should not switch lenses without consulting your eye doctor.
Which lens is better for astigmatism?
Both are designed specifically for astigmatism and can provide clear, stable vision. The better option depends on your eye shape and comfort preferences.
Are both lenses daily disposables?
Yes, both are daily toric lenses.
Which lens is better for dry eyes?
It depends on how your eyes respond, but MyDay Toric is sometimes preferred for its softer material, while Precision1 performs well for everyday comfort.