PRECISION1 for Astigmatism vs. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism
Trying to decide between PRECISION1 for Astigmatism and Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism? They are both popular daily contact lenses for astigmatism, but they use very different materials and technologies.
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism uses a moisture-rich surface designed to keep the outside of the lens hydrated. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism takes a different approach with HydraLuxe Technology, which is designed to work with your natural tears.
They also use different methods to stop the lens from rotating on your eye. That matters more than you might think. Contact lenses for astigmatism need to sit in a specific position for your prescription to work correctly. If the lens moves too much, your vision can become blurry until it shifts back into place.
So, while these lenses may look fairly similar on paper, they will not necessarily feel or perform the same on your eyes.
Your eye doctor will need to determine which one fits you properly, but knowing the differences can make that conversation a little easier.
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism is a daily disposable contact lens made by Alcon. You wear a new pair every morning and throw them away at night. There is no cleaning solution, no contact lens case, and no need to remember how long your current pair has been open.
The lens is made from Verofilcon A, a type of silicone hydrogel. It has a water content of 51% in the center, but the outside of the lens is where things get more interesting.
PRECISION1 uses SMARTSURFACE Technology to create a very thin moisture layer containing more than 80% water at the lens surface. Basically, it keeps more moisture on the part of the lens that actually touches your eye and eyelid.
For astigmatism correction, PRECISION1 uses Alcon’s Precision Balance 8|4 design. This helps the lens settle into the correct position and reduces how much it rotates when you blink.
Key Features of PRECISION1 for Astigmatism
- Replacement schedule: Daily disposable
- Material: Verofilcon A silicone hydrogel
- Core water content: 51%
- Surface water content: More than 80%
- Moisture technology: SMARTSURFACE Technology
- UV protection: Class 1 UV protection
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism is made by Johnson & Johnson. It is also a daily disposable lens, so you will use a fresh pair every day and throw them away when you are finished wearing them.
The lens is made from Senofilcon A silicone hydrogel and contains 38% water. Instead of creating a higher-water layer on the surface, Acuvue Oasys 1-Day uses HydraLuxe Technology, which is designed to mimic some of the natural properties of your tears.
The goal is to help your tear film spread smoothly across the lens so your eyes stay comfortable and your vision remains clear throughout the day.
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism uses Blink Stabilized Design to keep the lens in position. It has four stabilization zones that work with your eyelids every time you blink. This helps the lens quickly settle back into place, even when you are moving around or changing where you are looking.
Key Features of ACUVUE OASYS 1-Day for Astigmatism
- Replacement schedule: Daily disposable
- Material: Senofilcon A silicone hydrogel
- Water content: 38%
- Moisture technology: HydraLuxe Technology
- UV protection: Class 1 UV protection
What Do They Have In Common?
Both are daily disposable silicone hydrogel lenses made for people with astigmatism.
With either one, you put in a fresh pair in the morning and throw them away at night. You do not need to buy contact lens solution or clean and store the lenses between wears.
Both also include Class 1 UV protection and come in a fairly wide range of sphere, cylinder, and axis combinations.
The biggest differences are how they handle moisture, how they keep the lens stable, the prescriptions they offer, and the price.
Comfort
There is no honest way to say that one of these lenses will be more comfortable for everyone.
PRECISION1 has a very moisture-rich outer surface, while Acuvue Oasys 1-Day uses technology that works with your natural tear film. Some people will prefer the feel of one material, while other people will be much more comfortable in the other.
It also depends on more than the lens itself. Your tear film, eye shape, prescription, screen time, environment, and how many hours you wear contacts can all affect comfort.
How PRECISION1 Handles Moisture
PRECISION1 focuses on keeping moisture at the surface of the lens.
The center contains 51% water, while SMARTSURFACE Technology increases the water content to more than 80% at the outer surface. This gives the lens a soft, moisture-rich layer where it comes into contact with your eye.
If your current lenses feel good when you first put them in but start to feel dry later in the day, PRECISION1 could be worth discussing with your eye doctor.
That does not mean it will automatically fix dry eyes. There are several reasons contacts can feel dry, and sometimes the lens material is only part of the problem.
How Acuvue Oasys 1-Day Handles Moisture
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism uses HydraLuxe Technology, which is designed to mimic some of the natural properties of tears.
Instead of placing a high-water layer on the outside, the technology helps your tear film spread smoothly across the lens. Acuvue also designed the Oasys 1-Day family with long days and frequent screen use in mind.
If you already wear another lens from the Acuvue Oasys family and really like it, you may prefer sticking with a familiar material.
But again, there is no guarantee. A lens can sound perfect based on its features and still not be the right fit for your eyes.
Materials and Water Content
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism is made from Verofilcon A. It contains 51% water in the center and more than 80% water at the surface.
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism is made from Senofilcon A and contains 38% water.
At first, it may seem like PRECISION1 should automatically be more comfortable because it has more water. Contact lens comfort is more complicated than that.
A higher water content is not always better, especially for someone who already struggles with dry eyes. The material, surface, fit, and way the lens works with your tear film all matter. This is why two people can wear the same contact lens and have completely different opinions about it.
Lens Stability
This is one of the most important parts of comparing contacts for astigmatism.
Toric lenses contain different prescription powers in different parts of the lens. Unlike a regular spherical contact, they cannot freely spin around on your eye without affecting your vision.
If a toric lens rotates too much, your vision may suddenly become blurry. It may clear again after you blink and the lens shifts back into position. If your contacts ever seem like they need a second to “refocus,” the lens may be moving on your eye.
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism uses Precision Balance 8|4 design. The stabilization points are placed around the eight-o’clock and four-o’clock areas of the lens to help it settle quickly and remain in the correct position.
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism uses Blink Stabilized Design. Its four stabilization zones work with your eyelids to help reposition the lens each time you blink.
They are two different ways of solving the same problem. Your eye doctor can look at how each lens moves on your eye and determine which design gives you more stable vision.
Prescription Availability
Both lenses are available in a wide range of prescriptions, although PRECISION1 for Astigmatism currently has a slightly broader overall range.
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism is available in sphere powers from +6.00D to -10.00D. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism is available from +4.00D to -9.00D.
Both offer cylinder powers through -2.75D, but not every cylinder and axis is available with every sphere power.
For most common prescriptions, this may not make much of a difference. If you have a higher prescription or a less common combination of sphere, cylinder, and axis values, one lens may be available in your prescription while the other is not.
Your eye doctor can check the exact parameters before fitting you with either lens.
UV Protection
Both lenses include Class 1 UV protection. PRECISION1 for Astigmatism blocks at least 90% of UVA and at least 99% of UVB radiation. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism blocks 96% of UVA and more than 99.9% of UVB radiation.
That is a nice feature to have, but it does not mean you can skip sunglasses. Contact lenses only cover part of your eye and do not protect the surrounding skin, so you should still wear sunglasses that block UVA and UVB rays when you are outside.
Cost
Both lenses are available in 90-packs. One box generally provides a three-month supply for one eye.
At Blue Planet Optics, PRECISION1 for Astigmatism is currently priced at $124.80 per box. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism is currently priced at $115 per box.
| Lens | Blue Planet Optics |
|---|---|
| PRECISION1 for Astigmatism 90 Pack | $124.80 |
| Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism 90 Pack | $115.00 |
Prices can change, so check the individual product pages for the latest price before ordering.
At Blue Planet Optics, shipping is free and there are no hidden fees. The price you see on the product page is the price you will pay at checkout.
When you buy four boxes, purchasing three automatically gives you 40% off the fourth box, which can lower your total even further.
Which Lens Should You Choose?
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism could be a good option if you like the idea of a moisture-rich lens surface or need a prescription that is not available in Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism.
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism could make more sense if you already like Acuvue Oasys lenses, want a lens that uses HydraLuxe Technology, or are looking for the less expensive option between the two.
The right choice is whichever lens fits properly, stays in position when you blink, and gives you consistently clear vision. That is something your eye doctor will need to determine during a contact lens fitting.
FAQ
Are PRECISION1 for Astigmatism and Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism daily lenses?
Yes. Both are daily disposable contact lenses. You wear a new pair every day and throw them away at night.
Can I switch between these two lenses?
You will need an updated contact lens prescription from your eye doctor before switching.
These lenses use different materials, diameters, moisture technologies, and stabilization designs. Even if the prescription numbers printed on the boxes look the same, the lenses may fit and move differently on your eyes.
Which one is better for dry eyes?
There is no single answer because dry eyes can have several different causes.
PRECISION1 for Astigmatism uses SMARTSURFACE Technology to create an outer surface containing more than 80% water. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism uses HydraLuxe Technology to work with the natural properties of your tears.
One may feel noticeably better on your eyes, but you will probably need to try them with your eye doctor to know which one.
Which lens is better for screen use?
Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism is designed with the demands of frequent screen use in mind, but it will not automatically be the better choice for every person who spends a lot of time on a computer or phone.
We tend to blink less when looking at screens, which can make any contact lens feel dry. Taking regular breaks and making an effort to blink more often may also help.
Does PRECISION1 for Astigmatism have more water?
Yes. PRECISION1 for Astigmatism contains 51% water in the core and more than 80% water at the surface. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism contains 38% water.
That does not necessarily mean PRECISION1 will feel more comfortable. Water content is only one part of how a contact lens feels on your eye.
Do both lenses have UV protection?
Yes. Both include Class 1 UV protection. You should still wear sunglasses outside because contact lenses do not cover your entire eye.
Is PRECISION1 for Astigmatism better than ACUVUE OASYS 1-Day for Astigmatism?
Not necessarily. PRECISION1 for Astigmatism has a moisture-rich surface and a slightly broader overall prescription range. Acuvue Oasys 1-Day for Astigmatism uses HydraLuxe Technology and is currently the less expensive option at Blue Planet Optics.
The better lens is the one that works with your prescription, stays stable on your eye, and feels comfortable during your actual day.